Trash Talk

The plastic industry, unfiltered A newsletter from inside the plant

No. 3 · November 20, 2026

Your bag is made from gas. It is priced on oil.

A North American garbage bag starts at a gas well. This winter, natural gas is forecast under $3 and oil near $100. The bag is made from the first and priced on the second.

Illustration: a steel drum with a blank price tag tied to it

The Take

The polyethylene in a North American bag starts as ethane, a liquid pulled out of natural gas. A cracker on the Gulf Coast turns ethane into ethylene, and a reactor turns ethylene into pellets. The US Energy Information Administration (EIA) says cracking ethane can yield more than 80% ethylene. Naphtha, the feedstock refined from crude oil that is most common in Western Europe and East Asia, can yield as little as 30%.

So the cost of making resin here follows gas more than oil, and this winter the two point in opposite directions. In its outlook of November 10, the EIA expects the Henry Hub gas price to average $2.87 per million British thermal units from November through March, 36% less than last winter. The same outlook expects Brent crude to stay near $100 a barrel through the end of the year.

We think this is the most misread fact in a resin price. Cheap gas does not mean cheap pellets. US exports of ethane and ethane-based petrochemicals rose 135% from 2014 to 2023, so a pellet made on the Gulf Coast sells into a world market. On an earnings call on October 22, the head of a large producer said it plainly: global polyethylene prices are set by naphtha-based production. When oil is high, the world price is high, whatever the gas well charged.

It is not a free ride for anyone. On the same call, ethane prices were described as rising faster than natural gas. And the rule cuts both ways: when oil falls, naphtha plants become competitive again and the North American advantage narrows. The cost is local. The price is global.

What this changes for you. When a resin increase arrives with “feedstock costs” as the reason, ask which feedstock. Keep two public numbers side by side, Brent and Henry Hub. The wider the gap between them, the more the increase is about the world market and the less it is about the cost of making the pellet. Then ask whether the increase is nominated or settled. Only the second one is a price.

On the Line

A nominated increase is not a price.

What happenedOn November 16, Resource Recycling reported that September polyethylene contracts rose by 5 cents a pound, and that executives of two large producers backed a further 10 to 12 cents a pound in nominated increases for October and November combined. They cited feedstock costs, declining inventories and constrained production. On November 5, Plastics News reported that North American polyethylene prices rose again in October. Sources: Resource Recycling, November 16, Plastics News, November 5.

Our readNominated means asked for. For October, Plastics News reports another increase. As of November 20, we could not read a published settlement for November. For every increase, write down three things: what was asked, what settled, and in which month.

Freight will not hand the money back.

What happenedIn the same outlook of November 10, the EIA raised its forecast for the US retail price of diesel in 2027 to $5.03 a gallon, 12% higher than it expected a month earlier. It still sees diesel easing from 2026 levels, but it now assumes supply constraints through the end of 2027. Source: EIA, Short-Term Energy Outlook.

Our readA garbage bag is light and bulky. A trailer of bags is full long before it reaches its weight limit, so freight is paid on volume. With diesel at $5, carton size and pallet pattern are worth real money. Count the cases per trailer, not only the price per case.

The plastics appeal now has a calendar.

What happenedAt the Supreme Court of Canada, the notice of appeal in docket 42277 was marked complete on November 17. Attorneys general who want to intervene on the constitutional question have until December 14. The appellants’ written argument is due on January 18, 2027, and the respondents’ on March 8, 2027. No hearing date is set. Source: Supreme Court of Canada.

Our readWatch December 14. The provinces that step in will show how much of this case is about plastic and how much is about who gets to regulate it. Until the Court rules, the 2021 listing of “plastic manufactured items” as toxic stands.

The Number

61%

The jump in the price of high-density polyethylene after one week of cold in Texas, in February 2021. It reached 75 cents a pound in March, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas. The plants needed months to come back. Resin can move that much on a weather forecast, and no bag plant was touched.

On Air

Cover of the TrashTalk podcast

EP10 · What’s really in the price of a garbage bag

Out Friday, November 20, on Spotify. From a gas well to the shelf: the cracker, the railcar, the week Texas froze, and who absorbs the swing when resin moves. Next episode: ocean plastic, and who actually leaks it.

Listen on Spotify

Three to Keep

  1. North American polyethylene is made from ethane, which follows natural gas. Its price follows a world market set by oil.
  2. Gas is forecast at $2.87 this winter and Brent near $100. Read both before you read an increase.
  3. A nominated increase is a request. September contracts rose 5 cents a pound, and Plastics News reports another increase in October. Nothing is published yet for November.

The TrashTalk desk

Every figure checked against public sources.

Sources